Are Employers In Pei Required To Act On IME Recommendations?

Brief Overview:In Prince Edward Island (PEI), employers are not required by law to act on Independent Medical Examination (IME) recommendations. However, it is important for employers to carefully consider these recommendations as they can provide valuable insights into an employee’s medical condition and their ability to perform job duties.

No, employers in PEI are not legally obligated to act on IME recommendations.

Supporting Facts:

1. No statutory requirement: There is no specific legislation in PEI that mandates employers to follow IME recommendations.
2. Employer discretion: Employers have the autonomy to make decisions regarding workplace accommodations and return-to-work plans based on a variety of factors.
3. Importance of expert opinion: While not mandatory, IMEs offer professional medical opinions that can help guide decision-making processes related to disability management.
4. Consideration of legal implications: Failing to consider or address reasonable accommodation requests may expose employers to potential legal consequences under human rights legislation.
5. Collaborative approach encouraged: It is advisable for employers and employees, along with their respective healthcare professionals, insurers, and legal representatives, to work together in assessing the relevance and applicability of IME recommendations.


1. Can an employer refuse accommodation if it contradicts IME recommendations?
– Yes, although careful consideration should be given before refusing accommodation requests as this could potentially lead to discrimination claims.

2. Are there any circumstances where acting against IME recommendations would be justified?
– In certain cases where alternative solutions or accommodations can be implemented without compromising safety or productivity standards.

3. What role does the employee play in the decision-making process?
– Employees should actively participate by providing relevant medical information and engaging in open communication with their employer regarding their limitations and needs.

4. Can an employee challenge an employer’s decision based on non-compliance with IME recommendations?
– Employees may seek recourse through filing a complaint with provincial human rights commissions or pursuing legal action if they believe their rights have been violated.

5. Are there any guidelines or best practices for employers in PEI regarding IME recommendations?
– While not specific to PEI, various resources and organizations provide guidance on disability management, including the Canadian Human Rights Commission and provincial workers’ compensation boards.

6. Can an employer request multiple IMEs for the same employee?
– Yes, employers may seek additional IMEs if they require further information or clarification about an employee’s medical condition.

7. Is it advisable for employers to consult legal counsel when dealing with IME recommendations?
– It is recommended that employers seek legal advice in complex cases involving potential conflicts between IME recommendations and their obligations under human rights legislation.

Although not legally required, employers in PEI should carefully consider Independent Medical Examination (IME) recommendations as part of their decision-making process related to workplace accommodations and return-to-work plans. Collaboration among all stakeholders involved is crucial to ensure compliance with human rights legislation while addressing employees’ needs effectively.