Are Employers In Saskatchewan Required To Act On IME Recommendations?

Brief Overview:In Saskatchewan, employers are not legally required to act on Independent Medical Examination (IME) recommendations. However, it is important for both employers and employees to carefully consider these recommendations in order to ensure the appropriate management of disability claims.


No, employers in Saskatchewan are not legally required to act on IME recommendations.
1. The decision regarding whether or not to follow IME recommendations rests with the employer.
2. Employers should carefully review and consider the IME report before making any decisions about accommodation or return-to-work plans.
3. Acting upon reasonable and proven medical evidence can help mitigate potential liability issues for employers.
4. In some cases, consulting with legal counsel may be advisable when considering how best to proceed with IME recommendations.
5. It is essential that employers adhere to their obligations under human rights legislation when dealing with disability-related matters.


Q1: What is an Independent Medical Examination?
A1: An Independent Medical Examination (IME) is an assessment conducted by a third-party healthcare professional, typically requested by an employer or insurance company, aimed at obtaining objective medical information related to a person’s health condition or disability claim.

Q2: Are IME reports binding for employers?
A2: No, IME reports are not legally binding documents that require immediate action from the employer. However, they provide valuable expert opinions that should be taken into consideration during the decision-making process.

Q3: Can an employee challenge an employer’s decision based on non-actionable IME recommendations?
A3: Yes, if an employee believes that their employer has unreasonably disregarded relevant and valid IME recommendations resulting in unfair treatment or discrimination on grounds of disability, they may choose to pursue legal recourse through human rights channels.

Q4: What factors should be considered when evaluating the credibility of an IME recommendation?
A4: Factors such as the qualifications and expertise of the assessor conducting the IME, consistency with medical evidence, adherence to recognized standards of practice, and a thorough analysis of the employee’s functional abilities should be considered.

Q5: Can an employer be held liable for not following IME recommendations?
A5: While employers are not legally obligated to act on IME recommendations, failure to seriously consider reasonable and relevant recommendations may expose them to potential liability issues if it can be proven that their actions were discriminatory or in violation of human rights legislation.

Q6: Is it necessary for employers to obtain multiple IMEs before making decisions?
A6: The necessity of obtaining multiple IMEs may depend on the complexity of the situation and the availability of credible medical information. However, seeking additional opinions can help ensure a comprehensive evaluation is conducted.

Q7: What steps can employers take when faced with conflicting IME recommendations?
A7: Employers faced with conflicting or inconsistent IME reports should seek legal advice to ensure they make an informed decision based on sound reasoning and compliance with applicable laws and regulations.

While there is no legal obligation for Saskatchewan employers to act upon Independent Medical Examination (IME) recommendations, careful consideration of these expert opinions is essential. Adhering to human rights obligations and consulting legal counsel when needed helps protect against liability concerns while ensuring fair treatment for employees experiencing disability-related challenges.