Can Pei Employers Dispute IME Results?

Brief Overview:Employers in Canada have the right to dispute Independent Medical Examination (IME) results. However, there are certain factors and procedures that need to be considered before proceeding with a dispute. This article will provide an overview of the process and address frequently asked questions regarding disputing IME results in different jurisdictions.

Yes, employers can dispute IME results in Canada. Here are 5 supporting facts:

1. Right to challenge: Employers have the right to challenge medical opinions provided by IMEs if they believe there are valid grounds for disagreement.
2. Importance of evidence: To successfully dispute IME results, employers must present strong evidence contradicting the findings or conclusions made by the examining physician.
3. Legal requirements: Employers should ensure that their actions comply with relevant legislation and regulations governing disputes over disability claims and assessments.
4. Expert opinion: It is advisable for employers to seek expert opinion from qualified professionals who can review the IME report and provide an objective assessment of its validity.
5. Procedural considerations: Employers need to follow proper procedures outlined by insurance companies or legal frameworks when initiating a dispute over IME results.


1. Can I dispute an IME result if it favors my employee’s claim?
– Yes, as an employer, you have the right to challenge any medical opinion provided through an IME if you believe it is inaccurate or biased.

2. What grounds can I use to dispute an IME result?
– Grounds for disputing an IME result may include inconsistencies with other medical reports, lack of thoroughness in examination, potential bias or conflicts of interest on part of the examiner.

3. How long do I have to initiate a dispute after receiving the IME report?
– The timeframe for initiating a dispute varies depending on jurisdiction and specific contractual agreements between parties involved; however, it is generally recommended not to delay beyond 30 days.

4. What steps should I take to initiate a dispute?
– Review the IME report thoroughly, gather supporting evidence, consult with legal and medical experts, and follow the specific procedures outlined by your insurance company or legal framework.

5. Can I request a second IME if I disagree with the first one?
– In some cases, you may be able to request a second IME from a different physician; however, this will depend on the terms of your insurance policy or jurisdictional regulations.

6. Will disputing an IME result affect my relationship with my employee?
– While it is important to handle disputes professionally and respectfully, disagreements over medical opinions should not negatively impact your working relationship as long as proper procedures are followed.

7. What happens if my dispute is unsuccessful?
– If your dispute is unsuccessful at the initial stage, you may have further options such as mediation or arbitration depending on the specific process outlined in your jurisdiction or contractual agreements.

Employers in Canada can dispute IME results but must follow proper procedures and provide strong evidence contradicting the findings. Seeking expert opinion and complying with relevant legislation are crucial for successful disputes.