What Happens If An Ime Conflicts With A Personal Doctor’S Findings?

Quick Overview:When an Independent Medical Examination (IME) conflicts with a personal doctor’s findings, it can create confusion and uncertainty for the individual involved. In such cases, there are several important factors to consider, including the credibility of each opinion, the jurisdiction in which the assessment is taking place, and any relevant legal or insurance policies.

If an IME conflicts with a personal doctor’s findings, here are five supporting facts to consider:

1. Credibility of opinions: Assessing the credibility of both the IME and personal doctor’s opinions is crucial. Factors such as qualifications, experience, and impartiality should be taken into account.

2. Jurisdiction-specific regulations: Different jurisdictions may have specific rules regarding how conflicting medical opinions should be handled. It is important to understand these regulations within your particular jurisdiction.

3. Role of insurers/employers: Insurance companies or employers often rely on IMEs to make decisions related to disability claims or return-to-work plans. Their involvement may influence how conflicting opinions are addressed.

4. Legal implications: In some cases, disputed medical assessments may lead to legal proceedings. Understanding your rights and options within your jurisdiction can help navigate this process effectively.

5. Seeking additional medical opinions: If there is a conflict between an IME and personal doctor’s findings, it may be beneficial to seek further medical opinions from specialists or experts in the specific area of concern.


Q1: What should I do if my personal doctor disagrees with an IME?
A1: Start by discussing your concerns with both parties involved – your personal doctor and the organization conducting the IME – seeking clarification on their differing perspectives.

Q2: Can I choose not to attend an IME if I believe it conflicts with my personal doctor’s findings?
A2: Depending on your insurance policy or employment agreement, refusing an IME could have consequences such as denial of benefits or potential disciplinary actions at work.

Q3: Can I request a second IME to resolve the conflict?
A3: In some cases, requesting a second opinion through another IME may be an option. However, this will depend on the policies and regulations in your jurisdiction.

Q4: How can I ensure that an IME is impartial?
A4: It is important to research the organization conducting the IME and inquire about their processes for ensuring impartiality. Look for independent assessors who have no conflicts of interest.

Q5: What if there are conflicting opinions within my insurance company or employer’s medical team?
A5: If multiple medical professionals within your insurer or employer’s team have conflicting opinions, it may be necessary to seek legal advice to navigate potential disputes effectively.

Q6: Can I provide additional evidence from my personal doctor to support their findings during an IME?
A6: Depending on the rules and procedures set by the organization conducting the IME, you may be able to submit additional evidence from your personal doctor for consideration.

Q7: Are there any time limits or deadlines for addressing conflicts between medical opinions?
A7: Time limits or deadlines vary depending on jurisdiction and specific circumstances. It is advisable to consult with legal professionals familiar with disability law in your area.

When faced with conflicting medical opinions between an Independent Medical Examination (IME) and a personal doctor’s findings, it is essential to consider factors such as credibility, jurisdiction-specific regulations, involvement of insurers/employers, potential legal implications, and seeking additional expert opinions. Understanding your rights and options within your particular jurisdiction can help navigate these situations effectively while ensuring proper evaluation of disability claims or return-to-work plans.