Can An Employee Challenge The Findings Of An IME In Calgary?

Brief Overview:Yes, an employee can challenge the findings of an Independent Medical Examination (IME) in Calgary. However, there are certain procedures and requirements that need to be followed.

1. Right to seek a second opinion: Employees have the right to seek a second opinion from another medical professional if they disagree with the findings of an IME.
2. Request for additional assessments: Employees can request additional assessments or tests to further evaluate their condition and challenge the IME’s conclusions.
3. Gathering evidence: Employees can gather medical records, reports, and expert opinions that support their position and contradict the IME’s findings.
4. Presenting arguments in a dispute resolution process: If an employee wants to formally challenge the IME’s findings, they may need to go through a dispute resolution process such as mediation or arbitration.
5. Legal recourse: In some cases, employees may choose to take legal action against their employer or insurance company if they believe that their rights have been violated during the IME process.


Q1: Can I refuse to attend an IME if I do not agree with its purpose?
A1: While you may feel skeptical about attending an IME, refusing without reasonable justification could have consequences such as denial of benefits or potential termination of employment.

Q2: What should I do if I disagree with the findings of an IME?
A2: Seek advice from your healthcare provider first. If warranted, consider seeking a second opinion from another qualified medical professional who specializes in your specific condition.

Q3:Is it important for me to provide any evidence supporting my disagreement with the IMEs findings?
A3: Yes, presenting strong evidence is crucial when challenging IMEs’ findings. This might include comprehensive documentation of prior treatments received and statements from other healthcare professionals familiar with your case.

Q4:Is there any deadline for challenging an IMEs’ report in Calgary?
A4:The time frame for challenging an IMEs’ report in Calgary may vary. It is advisable to consult with a legal professional who can guide you through the specific deadlines and procedures applicable to your situation.

Q5: Can I bring someone with me to the IME appointment?
A5: Generally, employees are allowed to have someone accompany them during their IME appointment. However, it’s essential to check any limitations or requirements set by the employer, insurance company, or legal jurisdiction.

Q6: What if my employee tries to challenge an IME?
A6: Employers should consider engaging in open communication and addressing any concerns raised by employees regarding the IME process. Seek guidance from your HR department or legal counsel on how best to handle such situations compliantly.

Employees in Calgary have options available when they disagree with the findings of an Independent Medical Examination (IME). They can seek a second opinion, gather supporting evidence, participate in dispute resolution processes, and even pursue legal action if necessary. It is important for both employers and employees to be aware of their rights and responsibilities throughout this process.