IME Assessments in Slip and Fall Accident Sprain Cases

Navigating IME Assessments in Slip and Fall Sprain Cases

Slip and fall accidents are common occurrences that can result in various injuries, with sprains being among the most frequent. When pursuing a personal injury claim, the injured party (plaintiff) may be required to undergo an Independent Medical Examination (IME) to verify the extent of the injury and its impact on their life. Understanding the IME process is critical for plaintiffs as it can significantly affect the outcome of their case.

This article will serve as a comprehensive guide for individuals involved in slip and fall cases who are facing an IME. It aims to prepare them for the assessment, outline their rights, and offer strategies for ensuring the IME’s fairness and accuracy.

Table of Contents hide

Understanding IMEs in the Context of Personal Injury Claims

Definition and Purpose of an IME

An Independent Medical Examination (IME) is a critical evaluation conducted by a medical professional who has no prior relationship with the patient. In the context of personal injury claims, particularly slip and fall cases, an IME is often requested by an insurance company or a defendant’s legal team to obtain an objective opinion about the plaintiff’s reported injuries and limitations.

The primary purpose of an IME is to verify the extent and severity of the injuries claimed and to determine whether these injuries are a direct result of the alleged incident. In slip and fall cases where a sprain is involved, the IME seeks to assess the impact of the sprain on the claimant’s mobility, daily activities, and overall health.

Legal Requirements for an IME in Slip and Fall Cases

While laws vary by jurisdiction, generally, a request for an IME can be made by an insurance company when a claim is filed or during the litigation process if a lawsuit is pursued. It is a legal right of the defense to ensure that the claimed injuries are substantiated by an independent source, which means the plaintiff may be contractually or legally obliged to comply.

The Role of Insurance Companies in IMEs

Insurance companies routinely use IMEs in slip and fall claims to protect against fraudulent or exaggerated claims. The insurance adjuster handling the claim will typically select and schedule an IME to provide a report on the plaintiff’s injuries. It’s important to note that because the IME doctor is selected and paid by the insurance company, there may be an inherent bias, consciously or unconsciously, toward minimizing the perceived severity of the injury.

How IMEs Differ from Treatment by Your Own Physician

The fundamental difference between an IME and a consultation with a personal physician is the nature of the relationship. Your personal physician’s goal is to treat your injuries and promote your health. In contrast, an IME is not for the purpose of treatment but rather for assessment. There is no doctor-patient confidentiality in an IME, as the results are intended to be shared with the requesting party.

The Importance of IME for Sprain Injuries

Specific Challenges in Assessing Sprain Injuries

Sprain injuries, resulting from overextension or tearing of ligaments, are particularly challenging to assess due to their subjective nature. Symptoms such as pain and discomfort are self-reported and can vary greatly from one person to another. Moreover, the healing process for sprains can be unpredictable, sometimes resulting in long-term complications or rapid recovery. This variability makes it essential for the IME to be conducted with a high degree of professionalism and objectivity.

The Relevance of an Accurate Diagnosis to the Claim

An accurate diagnosis is critical in a personal injury claim because it directly influences the compensation the plaintiff may receive for medical costs, lost wages, and other damages. A sprain may seem minor but can cause significant lifestyle changes, and the IME must adequately reflect the injury’s consequences. If the IME underestimates the severity of the sprain, it could significantly reduce the settlement offer or affect the outcome of the case if it goes to trial.

The Potential Impact of an IME Report on Settlement Negotiations or Court Proceedings

The IME report can have a substantial effect on the course of settlement negotiations or court proceedings. A report that corroborates the plaintiff’s reported symptoms and treatment plan can lead to a favorable settlement. Conversely, a report suggesting that the injuries are less severe than claimed or not related to the slip and fall incident can weaken the plaintiff’s position, potentially leading to a lower settlement offer or influencing a jury’s perception of the injury’s legitimacy.

Preparing for Your IME

How to Document Your Injury and Symptoms Leading Up to the IME

Proper documentation of your injury and symptoms before your Independent Medical Examination (IME) is essential. Keep a detailed diary that includes descriptions of your pain levels, any instances of swelling or bruising, limitations in movement, and how the injury affects your daily activities. Record every doctor’s visit, physical therapy session, and any medications taken. This information can provide the IME doctor with a comprehensive view of your injury over time.

Tips on What to Wear and Bring to the IME

When attending your IME, dress in clothing that is comfortable but also allows the doctor to easily examine your sprain injury without obstruction. Avoid wearing excessive jewelry or accessories. Bring a form of ID, your medical records, a list of medications, and any imaging studies (like X-rays or MRIs) you’ve had. If you have braces, casts, or other assistive devices prescribed by your doctor, make sure to bring those as well.

Understanding What the Examiner is Looking For

During the IME, the examiner will be looking for consistency and credibility in your symptoms and injury presentation. They will assess the range of motion, swelling, tenderness, and other physical signs that corroborate a sprain injury. Be aware that they may also be observing your movements from the moment you enter the examination facility — not just during the examination itself.

The Do’s and Don’ts During the Examination


  • Answer the examiner’s questions truthfully and succinctly.
  • Follow the examiner’s instructions during the physical assessment.
  • Be polite and cooperative throughout the process.


  • Exaggerate your symptoms, but also don’t downplay them.
  • Discuss details about your legal case or settlement expectations.
  • Rush through the examination; take your time to accurately convey your limitations.

Legal Rights and Considerations

Your Rights as a Plaintiff During the IME Process

As a plaintiff, you have specific rights during the IME process. You have the right to know the credentials of the IME doctor and the scope of the examination beforehand. You also have the right to privacy and respect; the examination should be conducted in a professional manner without any unnecessary invasion of your personal boundaries.

What You Are Obligated to Disclose

You are required to disclose pertinent medical history and answer questions about the current injury truthfully. However, you are not obligated to provide information beyond the scope of the injury being examined or past medical issues that are irrelevant to the claim.

Legal Boundaries of the Examination

The IME should only assess the injuries claimed in your lawsuit. The doctor cannot perform procedures or tests unrelated to your sprain without your consent. If at any point the examination becomes uncomfortable or you feel it is inappropriate, you have the right to stop the examination.

How to Address Disputes or Disagreements with the IME Findings

If you disagree with the IME findings, you can dispute them. This usually involves obtaining a second opinion from another physician or having your own doctor provide a detailed report that contests the IME conclusions. It is crucial to consult with your attorney to address any disputes professionally and effectively, often through legal channels.

Strategies to Ensure a Fair IME Process

Selecting a Neutral and Qualified Medical Examiner

While the insurance company typically selects the IME doctor, as a plaintiff, you can still have a say in ensuring the physician’s neutrality. It’s within your rights, often with the help of your attorney, to object to a particular examiner if you can demonstrate potential bias or a lack of suitable qualifications. It may also be possible to suggest an alternative examiner or ask for a list of several doctors to ensure the assessment will be as impartial as possible.

The Role of Your Attorney During the IME

Your attorney plays a critical role in the IME process. They can help prepare you for the examination, advise you of your rights, and debrief with you afterward. While attorneys typically do not attend the IME, they may instruct a nurse or a medical consultant to be present during the examination to observe and take notes, ensuring that the IME is conducted fairly and according to legal standards.

How to Handle Inappropriate Questions or Requests by the Examiner

If the examiner asks questions or makes requests that seem inappropriate or outside the scope of the assessment, remember that you are not obligated to comply. Responding to such inquiries could provide information that’s not relevant to your case and potentially detrimental. Instead, politely decline and note the incident to discuss later with your attorney.

The Importance of a Second Opinion and How to Seek One

A second opinion is crucial if you believe the IME findings are inaccurate or biased. You can seek an independent evaluation from a physician of your choosing to counter the IME report. This medical opinion, if favorable, can be used to bolster your position and challenge the IME results. Be sure to coordinate this with your legal counsel to ensure that it’s done in a way that supports your case.

The Role of Expert Testimony in Contesting IME Findings

Utilizing Medical Experts to Support Your Case

When contesting the findings of an IME, it can be essential to enlist the help of medical experts. These professionals can provide a more detailed understanding of your sprain, its long-term effects, and how the injury impacts your daily life. Expert testimony can effectively challenge any aspects of the IME that may seem biased or incorrect by offering an alternative, expert perspective based on a thorough review of your medical records and personal medical assessments.

Criteria for Selecting a Suitable Expert Witness

Choosing the right expert witness is crucial. The expert should:

  • Have relevant medical qualifications and experience, particularly in orthopedics or a related field that deals with sprains and soft tissue injuries.
  • Be well-respected in their field, ideally with a history of publications or previous credible testimony experience.
  • Be objective and able to articulate complex medical information clearly and understandably.

The Impact of Expert Testimony on the Jury

Expert testimony can be incredibly influential to a jury, often clarifying the complexities of medical information and making it more accessible. A compelling expert can underscore the validity of your injury and its repercussions, potentially shifting the jury’s perception and impacting their decision regarding liability and damages.

Settlement Negotiations and Litigation After IME

How IME Findings Influence Settlement Negotiations

The findings from an IME can significantly affect settlement negotiations. If the report is unfavorable to your case, the defense may offer a lower settlement, arguing that your injury is not as severe as claimed. On the other hand, a report that confirms the severity of your sprain can bolster your position, potentially leading to a higher settlement offer. It’s essential to work closely with your attorney to understand how to use the IME findings strategically in negotiations.

Preparing for Litigation if Settlement is Not Reached

If a settlement cannot be agreed upon, your case may go to trial. In such a scenario, the IME report and your expert witnesses become crucial elements of your litigation strategy. Your legal team will prepare to address and counter the IME findings, emphasizing the legitimacy and severity of your injury. This will involve gathering comprehensive evidence, prepping witnesses for testimony, and constructing a compelling narrative for the court.

The Importance of Continual Medical Assessment

Throughout the settlement or litigation process, it is crucial to continue receiving medical care for your injury. Ongoing assessments not only contribute to your recovery but also provide updated evidence about the state of your injury. This continued documentation can prove invaluable, especially if your case takes a significant amount of time to resolve.


Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs) play a pivotal role in the adjudication of slip and fall cases, particularly those involving sprains. While they are designed to provide an unbiased perspective on a claimant’s injuries, their findings can significantly influence the direction and outcome of both settlement negotiations and litigation. It’s crucial for claimants to approach IMEs well-prepared, with a clear understanding of their rights and what to expect. Should the IME report not reflect the injury’s reality, it is within a claimant’s power to challenge the findings with credible expert testimony and ongoing medical documentation. Ultimately, an informed and strategic approach to IMEs and their aftermath can greatly impact the fair resolution of a personal injury claim, ensuring that justice is served and appropriate compensation is secured.

Key Takeaways

  1. Proper preparation for an IME, including thorough documentation of injury and symptoms, is critical to ensure the examination accurately reflects the claimant’s physical condition and supports their case.
  2. A claimant has the right to contest IME findings with expert testimony and additional medical evidence, which can be pivotal in challenging biased reports and influencing the outcome of the case.
  3. Ongoing medical assessments are essential for continuous evidence building, which is vital for strengthening the claimant’s position during settlement negotiations or litigation.

Historical Reference

The use of Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs) can be traced back to the early 20th century when workers’ compensation laws began to take shape in the United States. During this period, the need for impartial medical opinions to resolve disputes over workplace injuries became apparent. One historical example is the case of “Franklin v. Industrial Commission” (1917), where the Supreme Court of Illinois upheld the use of an IME to determine the extent of a worker’s injuries and the appropriate compensation.
In a recent example involving IMEs in a slip and fall in case in New York, the plaintiff suffered a severe ankle sprain after slipping on an unmarked wet floor in a retail store. The IME conducted by the defendant’s insurance company initially suggested that the injury was pre-existing and not a result of the fall. However, their legal team successfully contested the IME findings with testimony from a renowned orthopedic expert who provided evidence that the sprain was acute and consistent with a slip and fall mechanism of injury. This testimony was crucial in securing a favorable settlement for the plaintiff.

Further Considerations

  1. Evolving Legal Instruments: The concept of an IME may have roots in common law practices, where, historically, courts would sometimes appoint a “neutral” physician to resolve conflicting medical opinions, a practice which has since evolved into the formal IME processes used in contemporary personal injury cases.
  2. Standardization of IME Procedures: Despite their widespread use, there is no federal standard governing IMEs; the procedures and regulations can vary significantly by state, and even by local jurisdictions, affecting how IMEs are conducted and how their findings are applied in legal proceedings.
  3. Psychological Assessments: IMEs are typically associated with physical injuries, but they may also include psychological evaluations, especially in cases where mental trauma is alleged as a result of the slip and fall incident, which is a facet not commonly known to the public.
  4. Use in Disability Claims: Beyond personal injury cases, IMEs are often utilized in disability insurance claims, where insurers may require an IME to verify the extent of a disability before agreeing to pay out benefits, a procedure that has seen increased use as disability claims rise.
  5. Ethical Debates: There is an ongoing ethical debate within the medical community regarding IMEs, with some practitioners concerned about the potential conflict of interest when physicians are paid by insurance companies to perform these evaluations, which could influence their objectivity.

FAQs About IME Assessments in Personal Injury Cases

  1. What qualifications should an IME doctor have?
    • An IME doctor should be a licensed medical practitioner, ideally with specialization in the area relevant to the injury, such as orthopedics for sprains, and should not have any prior relationship with the patient to ensure impartiality.
  2. Can I refuse to undergo an IME?
    • Generally, if an IME is requested by an insurance company or as part of a legal process, you may be required to comply. Refusal could adversely affect your claim or case, but you can discuss concerns or objections with your attorney.
  3. Who pays for the IME?
    • Typically, the insurance company or the party requesting the IME covers the cost.
  4. Can an IME doctor provide treatment recommendations?
    • While an IME doctor can give opinions on the extent of your injuries and possible treatments, they do not provide actual treatment as their role is evaluative, not therapeutic.
  5. What if I am unhappy with the IME report?
    • If you disagree with the IME report, you can seek a second opinion from another physician, and your attorney can help you challenge the findings.
  6. How long does an IME take?
    • An IME can vary in length but typically lasts between 30 minutes to an hour, depending on the complexity of the injury being assessed.
  7. Is there a standard IME form or report?
    • While there is no universal standard form, most IME reports will include the doctor’s findings, the method of examination, and opinions on causation and prognosis.
  8. Can I bring someone with me to the IME?
    • It’s often allowed to bring someone with you, but they may not be permitted in the examination room. Always check the rules of the requesting party or jurisdiction before bringing someone along.
  9. How should I prepare for an IME?
    • Be familiar with your medical history related to the injury, follow all instructions provided by the requesting party, and consult with your attorney for specific advice on how to prepare.
  10. What happens if I miss my IME appointment?
    • Missing an IME appointment can negatively impact your claim or case. It’s important to notify the requesting party in advance if you cannot make it and to reschedule as soon as possible.

Glossary of Terms Used in the Article

  1. Independent Medical Examination (IME): An evaluation conducted by a third-party physician to provide an objective assessment of an individual’s medical condition, often related to a legal claim.
  2. Sprain: An injury to the ligaments caused by being stretched beyond their normal capacity and possibly torn.
  3. Plaintiff: The person who brings a case against another in a court of law.
  4. Defendant: An individual, company, or institution sued or accused in a court of law.
  5. Liability: Legal responsibility for one’s acts or omissions.
  6. Compensation: Money awarded to someone as a recompense for loss, injury, or suffering.
  7. Medical Expert: A medical professional with specialized knowledge and expertise who is called upon to provide testimony or opinion in a legal case.
  8. Bias: Prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with another, usually considered to be unfair.
  9. Orthopedics: The branch of medicine dealing with the correction of deformities of bones or muscles.
  10. Expert Testimony: A statement made by a qualified expert such as a medical doctor in a legal proceeding, intended to inform the court about scientific or technical matters pertinent to the case.
  11. Settlement Negotiations: Discussions between parties to a dispute with the aim of reaching a mutually acceptable resolution, often involving payment.
  12. Litigation: The process of taking legal action; the process of suing someone or trying them for a criminal act in a court of law.
  13. Documentation: Records, reports, statements, and other pieces of written evidence that are used to support a legal claim or defense.
  14. Negligence: Failure to take proper care in doing something, which can lead to damage or injury to others.
  15. Medical Records: Documents that contain a history of a patient’s medical background and clinical treatment.
  16. Prognosis: The likely course of a disease or ailment.
  17. Causation: The relationship of cause and effect, often examined in legal cases to determine whether one event led to another.
  18. Disability Claim: A claim filed by an individual asserting that they are unable to work due to a disabling condition and seeking insurance benefits.
  19. Rebuttal: A refutation or contradiction, typically used in legal contexts to describe a counter-argument or evidence.
  20. Ongoing Medical Assessment: Continuous medical evaluation of a patient’s condition over time, often critical in personal injury cases to establish the current state and progression of an injury.